top of page
Search

Controversy? Never by accident.

Oct 10
4 min read

Updated: Oct 11

As a girl who spends a lot of time online, I of course have seen the recently hot topic of yet another controversial Sydney Sweeney ad. This time, another topic that is controversial: female representation in sports. On Chinese social media, there has been a lot less discourse compared to her previous American Eagle ad, but I find it interesting because Sydney obviously knows about the consequences of her making those ads and this is also the second time she has done this. So why is she choosing to continuously make these controversial ads?

Just before we start, the content of this week’s topic, blog, and podcast episode is taken from the inspo of a Chinese content creator, Viola. She recently did a video talking about this phenomenon and I got inspired to do the same, with my own thoughts as a teenager.


People hated on the ads that Sydney did, and celebrities like Doja Cat and other female athletes have all responded to the two ads in their own ways. They are also part of the wider debate on Sydney’s ads, as some say that the ad is objectifying women or racist, but others might say that hey, Sydney is using those methods to make money and that’s a good thing. Yes are you surprised? Some people actually think this ad is okay. This debate however (like my video and this blog) will only help increase exposure for the brands, and when I say brands, I mean both American Eagle and Novig. The Novig wave has also helped American Eagle have another round of popularity and has also reduced Sydney’s cost of promoting herself and increasing her fame. All this controversy and debate is free advertisement for the brands because of the constant exposure. Despite people being unsatisfied, if we’re just looking at brands’ and Sydney’s increased popularity and fame, Sydney is very successful at this.


This method in marketing is the interpretation bait. People all have slightly different associations when they see this ad and when they share this and talk about it online or anywhere really, more would see this ad. The more that see this ad, the more exposure. So, Novig, American Eagle, and Sydney Sweeney are not really relying on the exposure of the direct ad to audience route, it is the ad-to-audience-to-interpretation-to-wider-audience route. This route is very effective especially for a small business like Novig and they are more worried about people not knowing about them and not having a wide enough audience than their “reputation”. They are a gambling site anyways, people who care about the brand’s or celebrity’s positive reputation will not go on a gambling site.

This is also an advertising polysemy as the ad attracts not only people who go on gambling websites, but also people’s different interpretations. This will also enlarge the brand’s consumer base and creates space for imagination of what’s next and what the ad actually means and symbolizes. This makes everyone who sees and talks about the ad part of the ad and makes the ad double, triple, quadruple in effect.


So all of this discourse will help Novig reach its target consumers very quickly, as with this level of exposure and debate, they are reaching everyone, so the rate of audience becoming consumer will be pretty high. However, if our debate is only fueling the brand, should we stop debating and just let it be? No, because if this happens relentlessly, people’s values will be broken and consumers will also get tired of this way of marketing after a while, which puts consumers between a rock and a hard place—should we just sit back and let it be or debate but fuel the brand’s fame and popularity?


On Sydney’s side, she becomes the center of controversy yes, but this is actually a double-edged sword. Sydney has thrown herself into a controversy cycle: the American Eagle ad connects her identity to controversial advertisement, and people start to associate controversial advertising with Sydney whenever they think about her, then the Novig ad comes out, and this creates more discourse and the media will be talking about her choice of making this kind of ad a lot more. This will then enhance promotional effects for both Sydney as a celebrity and the brands that she works with, making Sydney a symbol of being able to evoke discourse and conversation, aka improving her popularity. This might seem “good” for both the brands that she works with and herself but this all comes at a cost of Sydney not minding her own public image as it is already irreversible and that she keeps making those ads. However, the public might also get tired of always seeing her in those ads and eventually give up on talking about it. Because if the only thing that Sydney will show in those ads is her naked, then well, people will get bored and think that well “here goes another one”.


We also need to think about why Sydney is willing to “sacrifice” her public image like this. She is a registered republican, so a lot of her stances on social issues will differ from public expectations from a celebrity, and we also can’t forget that she runs her own lingerie brand, SYRN, and so all this sexuality and nude content is highly relevant to her identity and image as a celebrity (if you look on her Instagram).


As a teenager, first of all, I don’t think this ad is okay or should be tolerated in any way, and essentially everyone else online have said all that I want to say regarding its content and implications. Second, I think that although we should know that this is not okay, we should also not get carried away completely emotionally by this ad. I also hope that no actor or star of frankly anyone would ever have to use this method solely for public attention as it is derogatory and will only influence the younger generation falsely.


Let me know what you think on this!

 


 
 
 

1 Comment


Margaret
Margaret
Oct 11

Check out the podcast episode of this blog article: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPAROnk2kyc

Like
bottom of page