top of page
Search

The Chiba Mone Situation: as a Chinese Skater

11 minutes ago
5 min read

If you follow figure skating, you surely will know what recently happened at the Cup of China competition in Shenzhen, China. As a figure skater myself living in Guangdong, I wanted to go watch, but unfortunately couldn’t, but social media and the livestream gave me all the information I need. So here’s what I think about this situation.


First, figure skating has always been a subjective sport, and for it to be judged fairly, it has to be subjective. Sounds ironic, but it is true if you think about all the elements that go into the sport. All that the skater can do is to skate and skate to the best they can. Because of this, it is never the skater’s fault that they get overscored or underscored. We cannot overlook other influencing factors of scoring in the sport, but we have to keep this in mind when we move on to other aspects of this discussion.


Chinese fans love Alexandra Ignatova, we all do, it is impossible not to. I do too, but this doesn’t give me or anyone any reason to hate any skater who wins over her. That said, we need to see each skater as an individual, unrelated to anybody else’s performance. HOWEVER, Sasha did deliver 2 clean skates with no mistakes on her quad whatsoever, while Mone did make a mistake with her short program double axel, and this does make this argument more nuanced as of who deserves the gold medal. Some may argue that this is where the artistry kicks in, but hey, artistry is subjective too, so if we take that into account, it is still very hard to justify who is the “actual winner” because we all got our different perceptions as to how each athlete did.


Then comes arguably the biggest factor that made Chinese fans furious (well, including me): Mone’s comments on Chinese food safety. She was at the 2026 4 Continents Cup in Beijing and at those international competitions, athletes’ foods are all managed and monitored very carefully, so her comment was just really unnecessary. Her comment also stated that if anything were to happen to her doping-wise before the Olympics at the Four Continents Cup (the competition right before the Olympics), it would all be on her (aka due to the food at the Four Continents Cup in Beijing, China, so due to the Chinese basically). I guess if we look at it this way, all of what she said then is actually offensive to the Chinese as it is directly accusing the Chinese of being responsible for anything that might possibly happen to her body. But if we look at this from purely an athlete’s point of view, this is justified because a lot of athletes can’t even eat any meat 2 months before a major competition because eating meat would be a very likely factor to lead to a positive doping test, especially pork and chicken. I know this from this boy at the rink I used to skate at and he went to the Junior Grand Prix competition and 2 months before the competition, he couldn’t eat any pork or chicken because it will have a very high risk of getting him get a positive doping test result. And just overall, food safety is obviously very critical to ensure an athlete’s performance, given what had happened to Mr. Lazarev in Xi’an. But I guess the issue for me is putting the blame on a country entirely for a risk of this issue. Honestly, I don’t expect any country’s citizens to forgive me if I have said anything along those lines, even if I am an athlete who still competed and performed clean skates, because on one hand we’re talking about comments made that have touched the bottom line of a country and on the other we’re talking about an athlete doing their job to the best they can. You decide.


To my knowledge the audiences at Cup of China were angry because of predominantly two things: Mone’s comments about China, and the ISU’s unfair judging. I guess if we look at both together, to me at least, their actions are justified, especially because of Mone’s comments. Obviously, I’m not saying that unfair judging didn’t play a role, it definitely did, but I guess one has to be accountable for their own actions, both towards athletes and audiences.


Just a side note from me, I guess we can also tell that Alexandra’s popularity in China is still very very high and her performances did not disappoint!


Other athletes like Ilia Malinin and Amber Glenn have responded to this situation in their own ways, and their stances, looking at them without context, are justified from an athlete’s standpoint because I guess they also know how it feels to be skating onto the ice to claim a victory and have the audience boo at them, and if we look at purely that, yes, their stances are justified. However, if we look at this situation with context of what the Chinese audience remembers and also what happened with the judging, I would say that the audiences’ reaction is also justified. You can say that I am trying to be diplomatic here, but what I am trying to do is look at this from everyone’s perspectives and not just coming to a conclusion based on only one side’s reaction because this situation is multi-faceted.


There are two main biases the Western audience has about the Chinese audience that I would like to address here. One is that the Chinese audience booed Mone because of the China-Japan tension and other political issues China has had with Japan. However, that is not the case, although some may feel so. The second is that because both sides don’t really get where either sides are coming from with the differing stances, I guess this misunderstanding has led to some unnecessary debate and discussion, so to everyone out there, please have sufficient knowledge of the situation and context thoroughly before discussion happens. Also, I think the people who were booing any athletes at the competition should deal with the consequences they deserve, and the rest of the Chinese audience should not be attacked if they have not spread any hate.


Should audiences respect athletes’ performance regardless of their result? Yes, because all athletes can do when they are at a competition is to perform to their best, and if we solely look at their performance, yes, we should respect them. But, if we look at the situation with context, then this becomes more nuanced and we should think about things differently in this case.


This uproar really affected the ISU’s reputation in China, and a lot of Chinese audiences have returned their tickets and cancelled their entire trip to Chongqing. I can’t speak on their behalf exactly why they cancelled their trip, but I guess all factors should be considered.


For me, I still haven’t come to a conclusion yet as in a final conclusion of what I think about what had happened. Call me biased because I’m Chinese all you want, but the above are my thoughts.


Let me know what you think about this in the comments.

 


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page