When being from a place makes you better by default
In China, we’ve got two places where the people who are from there are very culturally arrogant and feel that they are superior to others, and in case you haven’t guessed it yet, they are Hong Kong and Shanghai. These two places in China are arguably the most culturally arrogant and superior, for me as a Mainland girl from Beijing.
Disclaimer: what I’m about to say is not to generalize every one of the population, it is just a societal phenomenon I’ve noticed that happens with only a part of the population and is a wider social phenomenon, but I have friends from Shanghai and Hong Kong who are nice people and do not treat people from other areas of China differently at all.
Let’s talk about Hong Kong first. Hong Kong was colonized by Great Britain for about 150 years, and let’s face it, most of the British population is made up of mostly white people, and Caucasian people do have privilege in this world with their skin color. So, this has made the older generation who have lived through Britain’s colonization feel so much more superior and arrogant by the fact that they have this certain whiteness in them and that simply because of that and how the British people have changed their society, they feel like they are on top of other Chinese people. This is why a lot of the older generation who have the old British passport of foreigners usually don’t want to change it to the new Hong Kong passport because the new one says “People’s Republic of China” instead of the British elements that is on the old passport.
Even though politically this is wrong, some people in Hong Kong still think that it “isn’t really a part of China”. They still feel like it is very British and foreign to the rest of the Chinese cities and regions. This makes them feel confident in their Hong Kong safe space and feel superior.
Some of those shops ran by people of the older generation even don’t allow Mandarin speaking customers into their shops, and there was even this ice cream truck that didn’t allow Alipay payment because it is a Mainland Chinese payment method. There has also been cases where taxi drivers don’t accept credit card payment because that requires a conversion from CNY to HKD, so they would always make Mainlanders pay with CNY so that they can earn 10% more than if they pay with HKD through bank account transfers.
As said, a lot of people from Hong Kong prefer treating people better with better English, but the problem is that in those cases of the older generation who have this prejudice, their English isn’t even fluent enough to talk with first language-level English speakers. This is not only with people in service, but just if you try to talk to a granny walking down the street, she will be very dismissive if you speak Mandarin but if you speak English, oh she will try her absolute best to help you, even when she doesn’t speak the language. I learned this the hard way when my parents and I went to arguably the most luxurious hotel in all of Hong Kong to have lunch and the waitress put on a very dismissive and judgy attitude when my mom spoke Mandarin to her asking about what iced beverages they had and the waitress was just very impatient and rude and didn’t answer her question at all, but when I put on my American-Born-Chinese English speaking attitude, the waitress was suddenly so nice to me and started listing out all the iced teas they had and I cut her off right off the bat when she started to list with “iced lemon tea, please” and my mom had the iced lemon tea she wanted :) It felt real good with that moment of revenge.
I think the younger generation of the HK population is a lot more inclusive and open-minded with cultures and Hong Kong’s history and Mainland and Mandarin. I feel like the Internet, international education, and social media all play a role, but I think that as time goes on, there will be a lot less discrimination and prejudice within the population, because well let’s face it: Hong Kong’s connection with Mainland will only get closer with the following years, with more and more population on either side moving to either side for international education, work, citizenship, etc.
I sometimes find it ironic that people from Hong Kong take so much pride in their history of being colonized by the UK. Other nations like India and the US take colonization as a shame on their people and celebrate their independence, but at least from what I’ve observed with a part of the HK population in the older generation, they really firmly believe in that this colonization has changed them inside out and they have every reason now to feel superior. I think that this is just white supremacy making its way into a population’s core beliefs, and well, it takes time to stop and completely eradicate this ideology.
I think with the conflicts China has been involved in throughout history and the humiliation China has faced in the past from Western nations and the rest of the world made part of the population feel like with a powerful, Western nation in their territory, they finally have a chance to be “elevated” on the world’s stage. With this in mind, I guess it is understandable that people may feel like they have become different to the rest of the nation, but this will never justify discrimination and hate.
When it comes to Shanghai, I guess it is the most iconic example of cultural superiority in Mainland China. In Shanghai, people feel like they are just more modern, chic, fashionable, and around the latest technologies and are just in general more sophisticated than the rest of the Chinese population. They think that other Chinese people are all “villagers” and from rural areas and only they are from the big city and the modern world, in Chinese it is something like “我是上海人,你是乡下人” (I am Shanghainese, you are just from a rural area/villager)
In Shanghai, the older generation obviously have had the privilege of witnessing the boom of the city and its rise to fame on the world’s stage, raising their house’s prices and making their roots in the city more valuable. I guess this has made the term Shanghainese more impressive, similar to if someone says they’re from Beijing, some may connote from a big city and having access to the more developed side of the nation and the world as opposed to being around a rural area (ahem, to some of the arrogant Shanghainese grannies I’ve met).
Even though Shanghai is definitely very modern and urban, other cities are catching up too. When I say that I mean that other cities are also catching up, I mean that they are also developing and advancing themselves at a rate faster than ever before. But even if someone says they are from a non-tier one city, this still doesn’t give people reason to be prejudiced against them.
But Shanghai has probably become the “international center” of Mainland China. Shanghai Fashion Week, the Victoria’s Secret events in the 2010s, Western restaurants and Gen-Z Chinese chains opening in Shanghai first because of its modern/chic customer base. People in Shanghai often look down upon people from Beijing because they think Beijing is not as chic and fashionable and modern as them, and they think people from Beijing are tacky and doesn’t have as much of a taste as them. For me, as someone from Beijing, every time I go to Shanghai, I always need to be careful and maintain my image as a proud and brave Beijinger. Obviously, Beijing is also a big and major city, but sometimes, some Shanghainese people just like to think that they’re more different because Beijing is a little less Westernized than Shanghai. I guess this will never change with the older generation, but again, just like in Hong Kong, I firmly believe that over time, with the younger generation opening up with their perceptions of different people from China, this will definitely become less of an issue.
People from Shanghai always like to talk about their Chinese ID number starting with 310 because that is the code for Shanghai and with that question, people can see if others are really Shanghainese. Shanghai is also a direct-administered municipality (直辖市), like Beijing and Chongqing, so I guess their power and influences against other provinces is really quite visible. But, again, that doesn’t justify hate and prejudice.
I guess this is a universal experience in almost every nation. People from bigger cities feeling sorry for people being from smaller cities and always feeling like they have access to the most recent resources and technologies as opposed to being “cut off” from the rest of the world.
I think that with the superiority that comes with people from bigger cities is their feeling of Westernization and globalization making their city more interconnected to the rest of the world’s big cities. This also has to do with English education and if one speaks English fluently with a true British or American accent, at least in China, they will most likely be seen as more impressive than people who only speak Mandarin. It is also a sign of international education, and with that already comes with privilege.
This is what makes Gen-Zs and the younger generation so much more open-minded and to me, the hope of more inclusivity and less prejudice amongst the world’s population. International celebrities, social media and online information all play a role in this change, and with this, I am quite optimistic about the future of preserving cultural pride and encouraging inclusion and positivity around discussion of culture and heritage.
But we are also vulnerable to single-story social media content of how one culture is portrayed on the Internet. On Chinese social media, there has been a wave of negative portrayal of India, for example, and to me, I can’t stop thining about how will the younger generation (including me) think about a nation when all I see about it is how negative it is and people saying that you should never go there. I’m not saying that all of what is said is false, but every culture and country is multifaceted, and one shouldn’t feel superior just because they don’t belong to a culture they saw in video being portrayed as “unwelcomed”.
I guess to some extent, cultural superiority is something people instill in their children when they are young and this will turn into something people genuinely believe and align themselves with because of this prolonged immersion in this mentality. This may change as people see more of the world and think critically why they might be taught so from a young age. But when I think about it, I think it starts with their upbringing and the history they remember then they start changing later.
But on a global aspect, a country or region’s international influence and presence also plays a big role in cultural superiority within people of that nation or region. A stronger economy, more top firms basing themselves in that region, more celebrities and people of top wealth living there—these are all reasons why people feel superior culturally. I guess it is valid, as it is a pride, obviously, but people from places without the above and without what people may deem as a “very strong economy” also has every reason to feel proud of where they come from, as confidence and pride should not be quantified to just a few numbers.
I say that and that should be the truth, but this is obviously not the case, as a stronger global presence and economy does help more of a culture be seen and represented, leaving some other nations being misunderstood or always being portrayed in a fragmented way because they don’t have that influence.
This also comes with personal influence and personal power over their presence, as some people may feel embarrassed by their own cultural background but may admire similar traditions and cultures when they are presented in foreign celebrities. I think celebrities play a big role is spreading culture around the world and I guess in the case of Chinese representation in the west, Jackie Chan is probably the most iconic celebrity representing Chinese culture and celebrities, making some associate being Chinese with knowing how to do Kungfu, which is obviously not true, but with the rise of Jackie Chan and his presence in entertainment, I guess more and more Chinese people have found themselves on the world’s stage and felt empowered. But with this comes stereotypes, just like what we just discussed about Kung fu, but as with everything, no effort comes with zero sacrifice or downside, so it takes time and more diverse associations with a culture.
I guess for the younger generation, we are moving beyond stereotypes with more international peers and media, but if all we see produced is single-sided information about a certain culture or tradition, then it will be hard for us to move beyond stereotypes too, so all we need is a little more critical thinking and the thought of: hey, what is actually beyond what I see here, to truly know a culture, reducing prejudice.
Every culture believes it has something valuable to offer, but we continue to rank them because of how they are represented in history and in society. So we either go down the path of repeating history and representing things in the way that they shouldn’t or we stop the ranking and purely focus on what we as individuals can see and understand about the culture, without assumption and superiority.
Let me know what you think about culture and people’s perceptions of it!
Mention to Wallace for giving me inspo for this week’s topic!






Check out the podcast episode of this blog article: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xUkN6eSYjUA